Movie Review by Sergio Martinez
This Italian film, recently released in Montreal, is
directed by Emanuele Crialese and stars Penelope Cruz, Luana Giulani and
Vincenzo Amato in the lead roles.
Clara and her daughter Adri, share time together in spite of some disagreements. |
The woman, who is certainly not happy in her married life,
seeks in her three children a sort of refuge from her own condition. Although
this relationship does not always flow as she would like it to.
This is especially true in the relationship with her eldest
daughter, Adriana (Luana Giulani), a pre-teen who is not comfortable in her
body, prefers to be called Andrea —a male name that in Italian is equivalent to
Andrew— and seeks some sign from outer space, as she claims to have been
conceived by extraterrestrials. Basically, the girl is transgender, but at a
time when there is no real understanding and even less acceptance of that
condition, her appearance and attitudes are taken as "oddities", somewhat
accepted because she is still perceived as a child. What the others do not know
is that Adri (Andrea) has already ventured, albeit very initially, in the
search for love.
The couple's children pose for a photo, Adri makes no secret of her discomfort. |
The other children, though younger, also hint at gestures of
discomfort: Gino (Patrizio Francioni), the middle boy, usually afraid of
disobeying his parents, will show it in a very unhygienic way.
The film portrays characters who struggle to be themselves, despite the constraints of family and social conventions. There is some symbolism in Adriana's (Andrea) search for a sign from outer space that, in truth, she may simply be looking for a sign of real affection from her immediate space.
In Adri's fantasies, her mother appears very different from her real life. |
Filmed especially in enclosed settings —the rooms of the
house, Adriana's classroom, or the school chapel— this makes the film reinforce
the idea of emotional confinement of the characters. The only escape is
provided by the fantasies of Adriana's imagination, which puts her mother in
scenes of exuberant musical displays, the opposite of her own life.
It is a film we recommend.
Released May 26 at Cinéma du Musée (French subtitles),
Cinema Forum (English subtitles) and Cinéma du Parc (English subtitles).
Running time: 97 min.