23.5.25

MOVIES AT LA PLAZA –JANE AUSTEN: WRECKED MY LIFE: Of Emotions and Quests

Movie Review by Sergio Martínez

“You don't live, you hide...” Félix (Pablo Pauly) once says to his friend Agathe (Camille Rutherford), the protagonist of this romantic comedy, that, in a very accurate way, transplants into its characters some of the emotions, vicissitudes and situations of the characters in Jane Austen's works. Somehow, those feelings experienced by the characters of the English novelist and some of the author herself converge, for better or worse, in the protagonist's personality and the events she experiences.

Camille Rutherford as Agathe
Agathe shares an apartment with her sister and her sister's young son in Paris. She works in the famous bookstore Shakespeare & Co, which specializes in English-language books, but her underlying passion is writing. Her literary endeavour, however, faces some obstacles: a writing block that often happens to her, the memories of her parents' death, and above all, her own insecurity.

Felix (Pablo Pauly) and Agathe
At the urging of Felix, her friend and colleague at the bookstore, and despite her strong initial resistance, Agathe enrolls in a program at the Jane Austin Residency in England, an opportunity to publicize her work, exchange creative experiences with other attendees and also to have some time to reflect on her life, mature her projects and meet new people in the quiet of the countryside. On the latter, the new writer will have many opportunities, the pleasant administrator of the Residency, Beth (Liz Crowther), her eccentric husband Todd (Alan Fairbairn), their son Oliver (Charlie Anson) and the other writers in search of inspiration for their literary projects. All this in a bucolic setting should help Agathe get to know herself better.

Oliver (Charlie Anson) and Agathe
For her, the influence of Jane Austen is powerful: “I’m living in the wrong century”, she says on one occasion. It is clear that the weight of the novelist's work is shaping her life, perhaps in a way that she may eventually come to regret. However, Jane Austen's literary legacy may provide her with something she did not foresee when she crossed the channel to that quiet retreat in the English countryside, recreating the atmosphere of the novelist's time. She would also find a romantic complement to her existence in that quest.

We fully recommend this film, directed by Laura Piami. It is very pleasant to watch. There are situations of reflection on how certain literary creations can influence us, but there is also a certain dose of humour and an ironic look at how we approach relationships in today's world. In Agathe's vicissitudes, there may also be reminiscences of the obstacles that the protagonists of Jane Austen's novels had to face.

Running time: 94 min.

CINE EN LA PLAZA—JANE AUSTEN WRECKED MY LIFE (JANE AUSTEN DESTROZÓ MI VIDA): De emociones y búsquedas

Comentario de Sergio Martínez

“Tú no vives, tú te escondes…” le dice en una ocasión Félix (Pablo Pauly) a su amiga Agathe (Camille Rutherford), la protagonista de esta comedia romántica que, de manera muy certera, trasplanta en sus personajes algunas de las emociones, vicisitudes y situaciones de los personajes de las obras de Jane Austen. Es que, de algún modo, esas sensaciones vividas por los personajes de la novelista inglesa y algunas de la propia autora, convergen—para bien o para mal—en la personalidad de la protagonista y en eventos que vive.

Agathe (Camille Rutherford)
aspira a ser escritora
Agathe comparte un apartamento con su hermana y el pequeño hijo de ésta en París, trabaja en la famosa librería especializada en libros de lengua inglesa Shakespeare & Co., sin embargo, su pasión subyacente es escribir. Su empeño literario, sin embargo, enfrenta algunos obstáculos: un bloqueo de escritura que le sucede a menudo, las memorias de la muerte de sus padres, pero sobre todo su propia inseguridad.

Su amigo Félix (Pablo Pauly)
la estimula a viajar a Inglaterra
A instancias de Félix, su amigo y colega en la librería, y pese a su fuerte resistencia inicial, Agathe se enrola en un programa de la Jane Austin Residency en Inglaterra, una ocasión para dar a conocer su trabajo, intercambiar experiencias creativas con otros asistentes y tener también un tiempo para en la tranquilidad del campo, reflexionar sobre su vida, madurar sus proyectos y conocer nueva gente. Sobre esto último, la novel escritora tendrá muchas oportunidades, la agradable administradora de la Residency, Beth (Liz Crowther), su excéntrico marido Todd (Alan Fairbairn) el hijo de ambos, Oliver (Charlie Anson) y las otras escritoras en busca de la inspiración para sus propios proyectos literarios. Todo ello en un bucólico ambiente el cual debe contribuir a que Agathe termine conociéndose a si misma un poco mejor.

Para ella la influencia de Jane Austen es muy fuerte: “Vivo en el siglo equivocado” dice en una ocasión. Es evidente que el peso de la obra de la novelista va conformando su vida quizás de un modo que ella a la larga puede llegar a lamentar. Sin embargo, el legado literario de Jane Austen puede ser que al final le proporcione algo que ella no previó cuando decidió cruzar el canal para ese quieto retiro en el campo inglés, recreando la atmósfera de los tiempos de la novelista. En esa búsqueda ella también encontraría un complemento romántico a su existencia.

Oliver (Charlie Anson) es quien
primero la recibe en Inglaterra
Recomendamos plenamente esta película, dirigida por Laura Piami. Es muy agradable de ver. Hay situaciones de reflexión sobre cómo pueden influirnos algunas creaciones literarias, pero también hay cierta dosis de humor y una mirada irónica sobre cómo enfocamos las relaciones en el mundo actual. En las vicisitudes de Agathe también puede haber reminiscencias de los obstáculos a los que tuvieron que enfrentarse las protagonistas de las novelas de Jane Austen.

Duración: 94 min. 

7.5.25

MOVIES AT LA PLAZA — “BONJOUR TRISTESSE”: Sadly boring

Movie Review by Sergio Martínez

It is said that when it comes to evaluating the quality of films, the criteria of three different judges are applied: the viewers, the critics, and the distributors. Needless to say, on many occasions, the evaluations that arise from them are very contradictory.

As a critic, I had the opportunity to see Bonjour Tristesse at the Toronto International Film Festival in 2024, and in the usual exchanges at the end of the screening for the media, everyone I spoke to agreed on the tedium that this film had produced in us.

Paradoxically, after almost a year, this film is now being presented on Montreal screens and, according to what has been reported by its publicists, also in U.S. theatres. What are the distributors or exhibitors thinking? Has the fact that the film was directed by a Canadian woman been an excuse? Or has there been a good work of contacts and influences here? I point this out because at the same festival we had the opportunity to see, for example, The Mother and the Bear, set in Winnipeg, directed by the Canadian of Korean origin Johnny Ma, or in terms of international cinema, a work of excellent quality such as Pedro Paramo (by director Rodrigo Prieto) or, if we want to talk about U.S. cinema, the very pleasant comedy-thriller Riff Raff by director Dino Montiel. None of these films has been programmed to be released in Montreal or other Canadian cities, which speaks to the narrow criteria of those who select the films that will later be shown in theatres.

On the other hand, and even with good pu
blicity and, we imagine, with sound financial backing, this production, which has no significant artistic merits, is being shown, and about which we reproduce here the critical appraisal it deserved when it was shown at TIFF.  And we dare to bet that it won't last long in theatres, viewers are not so masochistic.

Bonjour Tristesse—Directed by Durga Chew-Bose (Co-Production Canada, Germany)

The eponymous novel on which this film is based was a bestseller in the 1950s. Françoise Sagan, the author, wrote it when she was 18. The story, centred on the life of Cécile (Lily McInerny) a teenager whose mother has died, and who is vacationing on the coast with her father, Raymond (Claes Bang) and his girlfriend Elsa (Nailia Harzoune), attempted to portray the existential angst of a youth then besieged by the emptiness of life in a post-war France enjoying a growing posterity, while the specter of the Cold War seemed to overshadow their future. In this film, director Durga Chew-Bosse, we don't know if intentionally, introduces incongruous elements: the fashion, especially the actresses' swimsuits and the models of the cars make it clear that this is the period in which the story was written—the 1950s—yet, incoherently, there are also cell phones in the scene, which otherwise have no use in the story. A simple inconsistency and a lack of knowledge of the director? A deliberate resource, although without a clear objective? Many scenes are extremely tedious: how often do we want to see the protagonists swimming in the sea or sunbathing on the beach? In short, a remake of a novel whose subject matter is otherwise dated, and the director fails in her attempt, if she had one, to make the story relevant again.

We do not recommend this film because it is extremely dull, a judgment perhaps too categorical and one we rarely use, which fits this one very well.

Running time: 110 min.